commercial metal building siding

“Great group of guys from salesman to installers. Highly recommend for all your window and siding projects. Definitely will give them all my work.”

James Hardie Siding vs. Vinyl Siding

Transform Your Home with a Striking New Appearance:
Expert Siding & Windows Replacement Services Await!

Book Your Free Consultation

Request a FREE No-Obligation Quote & Expert Advice!

When it comes to protecting and beautifying your home, siding plays a critical role. Two of the most popular options on the market are James Hardie fiber cement siding and vinyl siding. Each offers unique benefits and drawbacks, leaving homeowners wondering which is the best siding material for their needs.

This guide compares James Hardie and vinyl siding across key factors, including durability, cost, aesthetics, and warranties. By understanding how these materials stack up, you’ll be better equipped to make a confident decision for your home.

replacement windows

Durability Comparison

James Hardie Siding

James Hardie fiber cement siding is renowned for its exceptional durability. Composed of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, it’s built to thrive in a wide range of climates.

Key Features:

  • Weather Resistance: Withstands extreme heat, rain, snow, and freezing temperatures with minimal wear and tear.
  • Fire Resistance: Non-combustible, making it an ideal choice for areas prone to wildfires.
  • Pest Resistance: Impervious to termites, woodpeckers, and other pests.

Lifespan:

James Hardie siding lasts 30 to 50 years or more when properly maintained, far outliving many siding materials.

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding, made from PVC (polyvinyl chloride), offers decent durability for its price point. However, it performs differently under extreme conditions.

Key Features:

  • Weather Resistance: Can warp or crack in extreme heat or cold.
  • Fire Resistance: Highly flammable and prone to melting when exposed to high temperatures.
  • Pest Resistance: Plastic composition resists pests, but it may buckle if birds or rodents try to nest behind it.

Lifespan:

Vinyl siding typically lasts 20 to 30 years, but it may need replacement sooner if exposed to harsh weather or physical damage.

Winner: James Hardie siding is the superior option for homeowners seeking unparalleled durability.

We Offer Financing

Our home improvement payment options help you create your dream home.

aluminum siding commercial buildings

Have questions?
Call now for a
free In-home consultation!

Full-Service Siding Experts in Sacramento

We Construct Into a Reality. 

Cost Analysis

Materials and Upfront Costs

  • James Hardie Siding: Costs range from $10 to $14 per square foot (including installation). While the upfront investment is higher, its long lifespan and minimal maintenance offset the expense over time.
  • Vinyl Siding: Costs range from $5 to $8 per square foot (including installation). It’s the more affordable option initially, making it attractive to budget-conscious homeowners.

Installation Costs

The installation process for James Hardie siding is more labor-intensive, requiring skilled professionals and specialized tools. Vinyl siding is easier and faster to install, which helps reduce labor costs.

Long-Term Value

James Hardie siding justifies its higher price tag with unmatched durability, low maintenance, and enhanced curb appeal. Vinyl siding, while more affordable upfront, often incurs higher lifetime costs due to frequent repairs or replacement needs.

Winner: James Hardie siding offers better long-term value, while vinyl siding suits those seeking a budget-friendly upfront option.

replacement windows

Aesthetic Appeal

James Hardie Siding

James Hardie siding is a design dream, offering an incredible range of styles, textures, and colors.

  • Style Options:
    • HardiePlank® lap siding for timeless elegance.
    • HardiePanel® vertical siding for modern, bold looks.
    • HardieShingle® siding to replicate natural wood shingles.
  • ColorPlus® Technology:
    • Pre-finished colors that resist fading, UV damage, and peeling.
    • Dozens of colors to match any design vision.

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding has evolved in terms of appearance, but its design flexibility is still limited compared to fiber cement.

  • Style Options:
    • Available in traditional horizontal planks and vertical panels.
    • Fewer detailed textures compared to James Hardie siding.
  • Color Options:
    • Fewer color options overall, and some shades may fade over time, especially in sunny climates.

Winner: James Hardie siding delivers superior aesthetic versatility and timeless beauty.

commercial building siding panels

Proudly Certified as Installation Masters

Achieving the Installation Masters certification signifies a high level of expertise and professionalism in installation processes. This esteemed certification is a testament to our team’s profound knowledge and skill in installation, adhering to the industry’s best practices and standards. It underscores our commitment to delivering outstanding quality and precision in every installation project we undertake, ensuring customer satisfaction and excellence in service.

Recognized by Angi for Excellence in Home Services

Earning recognition from Angi underscores our unwavering dedication and exceptional proficiency in the realm of home services. This prestigious acknowledgment is a reflection of our team’s deep-rooted expertise and steadfast commitment to upholding the highest standards in the industry. It highlights our devotion to delivering top-tier quality and unparalleled precision in every project we handle, ensuring our clients’ utmost satisfaction and trust in our services. This accolade from Angi, a renowned leader in home service referrals, not only honors our past achievements but also propels us forward, continually striving for excellence and innovation in serving homeowners.

commercial building siding panels

The Diamond Certified accolade

Achieving Diamond Certified status stands as a testament to our unwavering commitment and exceptional expertise in the home services industry. This esteemed certification reflects our team’s deep-rooted proficiency and our relentless pursuit of perfection in every project we undertake. It is a powerful endorsement of our dedication to maintaining the highest industry standards while delivering superior quality and precision.

Warranties

James Hardie Siding

James Hardie siding typically comes with a 30-year limited warranty on its materials. If you opt for ColorPlus® Technology finishes, you’ll gain an additional 15-year warranty against fading, peeling, and cracking.

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding warranties vary depending on the manufacturer. Many offer limited lifetime warranties, but these often don’t cover damages caused by warping, discoloration, or extreme weather.

Winner: James Hardie siding provides better warranty coverage for a worry-free investment.

Pros and Cons

James Hardie Siding

Pros:

  • Durability unmatched by other materials.
  • Resistance to fire, pests, and weather damage.
  • Stunning aesthetic options with authentic wood-like textures.
  • Long lifespan with low maintenance needs.
  • Extensive warranties on products and finishes.

Cons:

  • Higher upfront and installation costs.
  • Requires professional installation, increasing labor expenses.

Vinyl Siding

Pros:

  • Affordable upfront cost and fast installation.
  • Low maintenance requirements.
  • Resistant to pests and minor impacts.

Cons:

  • Less durable, prone to warping and cracking.
  • Limited aesthetic and color options.
  • Lower resistance to fire and extreme weather conditions.
replacement windows

Improve Your Exterior Today

No siding material is one-size-fits-all. Homeowners should choose their siding based on priorities like durability, design preferences, and budget:

  • If you’re seeking a superior, long-lasting investment that boosts resale value and provides low-maintenance beauty, James Hardie siding is your best bet.
  • If you need an affordable solution with a quicker installation time, vinyl siding might suit your needs better.

For personalized guidance on choosing the best siding for your home, or to receive a free consultation and quote, contact our team today. Whether you choose James Hardie or vinyl siding, we’ll help you achieve a stunning home exterior that lasts. 

Why Our Customers Trust Us

  • Heritage replaced my old crumbling wood siding and did a fantastic job From the first interactions in terms of assessing Read More

  • Heritage Exteriors is beyond exceptional Very impressed with the timeliness communication and reasonable price of the whole project We started Read More

  • Excellent Experience with Heritage Exteriors We recently had James Hardie siding and Milgard windows installed by Heritage Exteriors and the Read More

  • Heritage did an outstanding job with our exterior siding and windows David our salesperson was incredibly knowledgeable personable and an Read More

  • We recently had our house re-sided with Hardie product We interviewed companies one of them being Heritage Exteriors From our Read More

  • We recently bought our house and our windows were much needed upgrade Heritage window and siding was highly recommended by Read More

  • From estimate to clean up - David and Alex's staff were wonderful Excellent attention to detail and very professional Removed Read More

  • I had many estimates for siding and changing out a window for a French door theirs was the most reasonable Read More

  • From start to finish the crew from Heritage was very professional with wonderful craftsmanship I had several other trades comment Read More

  • I recently had Heritage Exteriors replace all of the siding and windows on my home and I couldn t be Read More

  • This summer we decided that it was time to replace the original cedar siding on our south side of our Read More

  • -Star Review for Heritage Exterior I recently had the pleasure of working with Heritage Exterior for a complete upgrade of Read More

  • My wife and I had been talking about replacing our cement board siding for years but I was lucky to Read More

  • Very pleased with the work the guys at heritage exteriors did on my house I got multiple quotes with companies Read More

  • Very satisfied with cooperation with Heritage exteriors A few months ago I decided to update the look of my house Read More

  • Absolutely wonderful experience from the initial consult to the install and follow up I have utilized them on different occasions Read More

  • Vitalii and his crew are great to work with They helped me transform my s ranch with peeling paint and Read More

  • Needed siding replaced on a project I had a really good and easy experience working with Heritage Good Communication and Read More

  • David was an absolute pleasure to work with He actually stopped by twice to answer all of my questions about Read More

  • Heritage Exteriors did a great job on our siding and paint project They were able to complete everything we needed Read More

  • David and Greg make a great team and their crew does amazing work I hired them to finish a James Read More

  • I would like to give this company a very great review I'll start with Dave being so kind and very Read More

  • We hired Heritage Exteriors to take over a siding project that had been started by a contractor I had to Read More

  • I needed some windows replaced in my home and got window quotes They all ranged different in price and brand Read More

  • The Heritage Exteriors sales rep and the crew worked hard and well to replace all of the siding and windows Read More

  • Heritage Exteriors did an excellent job removing the stucco from the exterior of our house and replacing it with siding Read More

  • Wow for Heritage Exteriors Excellent job installing my windows The crew was clean and respectful and most important did a Read More

  • Awesome experience Heritage Exteriors handled our siding fascia doors and windows They have a great team of hard workers that Read More

  • This company did a full house siding and window replacement for us The team was polite efficient and hard working Read More

  • David and the entire crew at Heritage Exteriors were very pleasant to work with They did an outstanding job on Read More

  • It has been a great experience with this company putting new siding s for are home Everyone has been very Read More

  • We made the wise decision of choosing Heritage Exteriors Siding to prepare our home in the Bay Area for sale Read More

  • The best siding company in town. Extremely happy with the work done. Responsible and qualified company employees. Only 5 stars🔥🔥🔥

  • Hands down the best window installation company I've ever had the pleasure of working with From the initial consultation to Read More

  • Heritage resided and installed new windows in our duplex in sacramento and we couldn t be happier They took the Read More

  • Heritage Exteriors replaced windows and door on one of my rental properties Did amazing job the crew was respectful and Read More

  • Great group of guys from salesman to installers Highly recommend for all your window and siding projects Definitely will give Read More

  • Great company. Easy to work with. Great craftsmanship. Loved my new siding and windows. Thank you Alex ,David, Vitalii.

  • From design w David to completion w Alex Roman and the team Heritage Exterior's met our project with enthusiasm excellence Read More

  • I am thrilled to recommend this company They replaced all of my windows and removed my old vinyl siding replacing Read More

  • Very professional company David the owner went above and beyond to explain all the details The siding crew was on Read More

  • Heritage exteriors did the siding and windows at my place They were professional and impressively fast at getting the work Read More

  • Ordered work from these guys. They did everything perfectly and quickly. Thank you team

  • My new windows and siding are Awesome Very professional and hard working crew David made sure any of my concerns Read More

  • Amazing quality integrity and professionalism I'm a local General Contractor and finding subs who show up on time and keep Read More

  • They did amazing job on my siding and windows. Definitely will recommend Heritage Exteriors to all my family and friends.

  • STAR COMPANY Thank you for the sense of urgency getting the project done ahead of schedule Great team that ALWAYS Read More

  • I had seen the home You have to see it yourself The art is greatly appreciated

  • Great people, easy to work with, efficient and quality work! Will definitely reach out again for any door replacement needs.

  • Very happy with my siding. Highly recommend. Always on time. Price was fair. Thank you Heritage Team.

  • Very professional company. I loved working with Heritage Exteriors. My new siding and window look beautiful

  • They did siding on my house, Exceptional job, punctually, very kind workers, and great rates

  • Picture Perfect then/ Heritage now....windows were nicely installed & look & work great...thanx

  • Amazing job would recommend to my friends and family. Quick easy and pleasant experience

  • Amazing craftsmanship, experience, and professionalism.

  • Heritage travelled up to Tahoe to reside our home with a pre painted James Hardie system This is the way Read More

Visit Our Office

Hexteriors Siding & Windows, established in Sacramento in 2014, has earned a reputation for providing reliable supply and installation services for sidings and windows throughout the region.

commercial building siding panels