The Craftsman home is more than just an architectural style; it’s a philosophy. Born from the Arts and Crafts movement, it celebrates simplicity, natural materials, and visible, honest craftsmanship. Across California, from the historic bungalows of Pasadena to the charming neighborhoods of the Bay Area and Sacramento, these homes are treasured for their warmth, character, and enduring design. The siding is a primary element of this character, using a rich vocabulary of textures, patterns, and profiles to create a look that is both substantial and welcoming.
At Heritage Exteriors Siding & Windows, we are specialists in restoring and renovating California Craftsman exterior designs. We understand that choosing the right siding is about more than just protection; it’s about honoring an architectural legacy. It requires a deep knowledge of the style’s defining features and an expert command of both traditional and modern materials that can capture its authentic spirit. This guide is for California homeowners who wish to preserve the integrity of their Craftsman home while enhancing its beauty and durability for the 21st century.
Preserve and Perfect Your Craftsman Home’s Exterior
From authentic cedar shingles to durable fiber cement, we help you choose the right materials to honor your home’s architectural heritage.
Schedule Your Free Craftsman Design Consultation Today!
What Defines a Craftsman-Style Exterior
A Craftsman home is immediately recognizable by its distinct set of features, all of which work in harmony to create a cohesive and grounded appearance. The design emphasizes a connection to the earth and showcases the hand of the builder. Understanding these core elements is the first step in making appropriate siding and trim choices.
Natural Materials and Hand-Crafted Details
The Arts and Crafts movement was a reaction against the mass-produced ornamentation of the Victorian era. Craftsman design, therefore, places a high value on materials that look and feel natural. Wood, stone, and brick are the foundational elements. This philosophy extends to the details: the visible joinery, the substantial trim, and the way different materials are layered together. The “hand-crafted” feel comes from the intentional and visible construction details, celebrating the skill of the artisan.
Low Pitched Roofs and Deep Eaves
Craftsman homes are known for their low-pitched, gabled roofs with wide, overhanging eaves. This strong horizontal roofline gives the homes a distinctive, grounded profile that makes them look like they are rising naturally from the landscape.
- Deep Eaves and Exposed Rafter Tails: The deep eaves are not just a stylistic choice; they provide shade and protect the siding from rain. A signature detail is the exposed rafter tails, where the ends of the roof rafters are left visible under the eaves, showcasing the home’s structure and creating a rhythmic, decorative pattern.
- Porch-Centric Facades: The front porch is the heart of a Craftsman home. It’s typically large and covered by the main roofline, serving as an outdoor living room. The porch is supported by substantial, often tapered, columns that rest on heavy piers made of stone, brick, or wood. This porch-centric design creates a welcoming and community-oriented facade.
- Tapered Columns: The square columns that support the porch roof are a defining feature. They are often wider at the base and taper elegantly as they rise. This detail adds to the sense of solidity and handcrafted quality.
Traditional Siding Materials Used in Craftsman Design
The classic Craftsman siding California look is achieved through a rich mix of siding profiles and textures, typically using wood. Different siding styles are often used on different parts of the house to break up the massing and add visual interest.
Cedar Shingles and Lap Siding
Wood is the quintessential material for a Craftsman home, and cedar is the traditional species of choice due to its natural resistance to rot and insects.
- Cedar Shingles: Often used in the large gables of the roof or on the upper half of a two-story home,
cedar shingle Craftsmansiding adds beautiful texture and shadow lines. They are typically installed with a straight, even coursing, but a staggered butt-end can be used for a more rustic look. The scale is important; shingles should be of a size that complements the scale of the gable. - Lap Siding: Wide wood lap siding is the workhorse of the Craftsman exterior, typically used on the main body of the home. The boards are substantial, often with an exposure of 6 to 8 inches, reinforcing the home’s horizontal lines and solid presence.
- Installation Notes: Proper installation is critical for longevity. A starter course is needed to set the correct angle for the first row of siding. Corner boards are typically wide and substantial, made from thick trim stock to give the corners a solid, defined look. Meticulous flashing around windows, doors, and at all transition points is non-negotiable to prevent water intrusion.
Board-and-Batten Accents
While not as common as shingles or lap siding for the entire house, board-and-batten is frequently used as an accent material, particularly on the lower portion of porch columns, on dormers, or within smaller gable ends. This vertical siding profile consists of wide boards with their seams covered by narrower strips called battens. This verticality provides a pleasing contrast to the dominant horizontal lines of the lap siding and roof.
Modern Alternatives That Preserve the Craftsman Look
While traditional wood is beautiful, it requires significant maintenance, especially in California’s diverse climates. Fortunately, modern materials now offer the authentic Craftsman aesthetic with vastly superior durability, fire resistance, and lower maintenance requirements.
Fiber Cement and Engineered Wood
These two materials are the leading choices for homeowners who want a long-lasting, low-maintenance Craftsman exterior.
- Fiber Cement: This is an ideal material for replicating the Craftsman look.
Fiber cement Craftsman sidingis available in a huge variety of profiles, including smooth and textured lap siding in various widths, shingles/shakes for gables, and panels for creating board-and-batten accents or soffits.- Pros: It’s non-combustible (a huge advantage in California’s fire zones), impervious to rot and pests, and holds paint exceptionally well. Factory-finished products come with long warranties against fading and chipping.
- Cons: It’s heavier and more brittle than wood, requiring specialized tools and installation expertise. The upfront cost can be higher than other options.
- Engineered Wood: Products like LP SmartSide provide a very realistic wood-grain texture and are a popular choice for achieving the
engineered wood Craftsmanlook.- Pros: It’s lighter than fiber cement, easier to cut and install, and comes in long lengths that can reduce seams. It’s factory-treated to resist rot and termites and is highly impact-resistant.
- Cons: While highly resistant, it is not as fireproof or waterproof as fiber cement. Meticulous sealing of all cut edges during installation is absolutely critical to protect the composite core.
Eco-Friendly Composite Siding
A growing category of composite siding materials, often made from a blend of recycled polymers and other materials, offers another sustainable, low-maintenance option. These products can be molded into various textures and profiles, including those suitable for Craftsman homes. They offer excellent moisture resistance and color retention, providing another avenue for homeowners focused on durability and environmental responsibility.
Choosing Authentic Color Palettes
The Craftsman color palettes are inspired by the natural world. The goal is to create a harmonious relationship between the house and its landscape, using colors found in stone, soil, bark, and foliage.
Warm Earth Tones and Muted Greens
These are the quintessential Craftsman colors. Think of deep olive and mossy greens, rich chocolate browns, warm ochres, and dusky reds. These colors are complex and muted, not bright or primary. They give the home a sense of belonging to its environment. The main body of the house is typically painted in one of these earthy shades.
Coordinating Trim and Accent Colors
The trim is a crucial part of the color scheme and is rarely pure white.
- Trim Color: Craftsman trim (fascia boards, rafter tails, corner boards, window casings) is usually painted in a contrasting color that complements the main body color. A warm, creamy off-white is a classic choice that provides a crisp outline without the starkness of a bright white. Alternatively, a darker shade, such as a deep brown or a darker version of the body color, can be used for a more subtle, sophisticated look.
- Accent Color: A third, bolder color is often reserved for a specific accent, most famously the front door. This is where you can introduce a pop of color like a deep burgundy, a forest green, or a rich goldenrod to draw the eye and create a welcoming focal point.
- Finish Sheen: A low-lustre finish, such as satin or eggshell, is most appropriate for the body and trim of a Craftsman home. High-gloss paints can look plastic and out of character.
Custom Trim and Detail Work for Authenticity
It’s the details that truly make a Craftsman home sing. Generic, undersized trim will undermine the entire aesthetic. Authenticity lies in the substance and layering of the trim work.
- Belly Bands and Water Tables: A “belly band” is a wide, horizontal trim board that is often used to separate the siding on the first and second floors, or to separate different siding materials (like lap siding below and shingles above). A “water table” is a similar board at the base of the wall, often angled at the top to shed water. These bands add another layer of horizontal emphasis and detail.
- Tapered Column Wraps: The signature tapered porch columns are a complex piece of craftsmanship. They can be wrapped in smooth wood, engineered wood, or fiber cement panels, often with their own base and cap trim details that add to their visual weight.
- Window and Door Trim: Craftsman window trim is substantial. It’s typically built up from several layers of flat stock, often with a wider header piece and a projecting sill at the bottom. A common width for the side casings and header is 4 to 6 inches, giving the windows a strong, defined frame.
Siding Patterns and Profiles That Elevate Craftsman Aesthetics
The interplay of different siding patterns is key to an authentic design. A common and highly effective strategy is to use wide horizontal lap siding on the main body of the first floor. This grounds the house. The upper floor or, more commonly, the large front-facing gable, is then clad in shingles. This change in texture breaks up the facade and adds visual interest. The scale of the shingles and the exposure of the lap siding should be in proportion to the size of the house to feel balanced.
Weather and Durability Considerations Across California Regions
California’s diverse geography demands a region-specific approach to material selection.
- Coastal Fog (Bay Area, Central Coast): In areas with persistent fog and salt air, moisture resistance is paramount. Fiber cement is an outstanding choice here, as it is impervious to rot and will not be corroded by salt. Meticulous caulking and painting are crucial for wood or engineered wood to prevent moisture intrusion.
- Inland Heat (Central Valley, SoCal Valleys): Intense UV exposure and heat are the main challenges. Siding materials with factory-applied, UV-resistant finishes are highly recommended, as they will resist fading and chalking far better than a standard field-applied paint job. Lighter colors will also absorb less heat, reducing stress on the material.
- Foothill Fire Zones (Sierra Nevada, Santa Cruz Mountains): In any designated Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI) zone, non-combustible siding is the only responsible choice. Class A fire-rated fiber cement is the industry standard for creating a fire-resistant exterior.
- Sierra Snow (Tahoe, High Country): In areas with heavy snowfall, durability and water management are key. Siding must be able to withstand the weight of snow piled against it and the constant freeze-thaw cycles. Again, fiber cement and properly installed engineered wood perform well. Excellent flashing and water management systems are non-negotiable.
How Proper Installation Preserves Craftsmanship
The most authentic materials and design will fail if the installation is poor. True craftsmanship is revealed in the technical execution.
- Water-Resistive Barrier (WRB) and Flashing: The home’s “raincoat” must be perfect. This means a continuously installed WRB (house wrap) that is properly integrated with flashing at every single penetration: every window, door, porch roof intersection, and trim board.
- Rainscreen Systems: For the ultimate in durability, especially in wet climates, installing the siding as a rainscreen (with an air gap behind it) allows the wall assembly to drain and dry completely, preventing moisture issues and dramatically extending the life of the siding and paint.
- Sealing Cut Edges: When using wood or engineered wood, every single cut edge made on site must be primed and sealed before installation. This prevents water from wicking into the core of the board, which is the primary cause of failure.
- Fastener Selection: Using the correct, corrosion-resistant fasteners (like stainless steel or hot-dipped galvanized nails) is critical. The wrong fastener will rust and cause ugly stains on the siding.
Common Renovation Pitfalls to Avoid
- “Vinylizing” the Details: Removing original wood trim and wrapping it in aluminum or vinyl is a common mistake that strips the home of its character. The sharp, handcrafted edges of the wood are lost.
- Undersized Trim: Using standard, narrow trim from a big-box store will make the home look cheap and inauthentic. Craftsman trim is substantial and often built-up.
- Ignoring the Mix of Textures: Using a single siding material all over the house can make it look flat. The interplay of lap siding and shingles is a hallmark of the style.
- Inappropriate Window Choices: Replacing original wood windows with vinyl windows that have bulky frames or fake grids can severely compromise the home’s historic character.
Work with California’s Craftsman Home Siding Specialists
A Craftsman home is a special kind of property that deserves a special kind of contractor. It requires a team that appreciates the architectural philosophy, understands the historical details, and has the technical skill to execute them with modern, high-performance materials.
The experts at Heritage Exteriors Siding & Windows are passionate about preserving the legacy of California’s Craftsman homes. We combine a designer’s eye with a craftsman’s hand to create exteriors that are both historically authentic and built to last. We can guide you through every decision, from material selection and color palettes to the intricate trim details that will make your home shine. To learn more about our comprehensive siding services, please visit our main installation page.
Let Us Help You Honor Your Home’s Craftsman Legacy
Our team specializes in the authentic materials, colors, and trim details that define the Craftsman style. Let’s create an exterior that lasts a lifetime.
